At this time, please do not use this recipe. Several people have recently had poor outcomes with it. I am currently on my honeymoon and so am away from the notes I made when I initially used this recipe, as well as the original source, so I can’t check the amounts to determine where the problem lies. When I return home, I will check it out and make any necessary corrections. I apologize to the people who have had undesirable results using these directions.
-Marisa, October 2, 2009
Oh asparagus! How I avoided pickling you. I kept you waiting in the fridge for over a week, as you anticipated your spicy vinegar bath. And yet, already you’ve given me so much! After just two days of pickling, you are the perfect balance of crisp and pucker. You make the perfect sidecar to just about any meal. I am enamored.
That’s right kids, the pickled asparagus has turned out to be a riotous success, despite the fact that I used asparagus that was a tiny bit past its prime (life, why much you always throw distractions into my canning schedule?) and forgot to include the peppercorns in the brine.
I based my recipe on one from Putting Up, a really terrific book about Southern-style canning that was recommended to me by my friend Taylor. It’s by Stephen Palmer Dowdney, who ran a successful canning business in Charleston, SC for many years (although I’m far more impressed by the fact that he was a college classmate of Pat Conroy, who is one of my favorite authors). If you’re looking to expand your food preservation reference library (I make it sound so official, don’t I), this is definitely a volume to consider. I like how it’s organized by month, as well as the fact that it has really excellent details on the basics of canning.
Before we get into the recipe, I want to take a moment to encourage all of you to consider pickling something. Possibly even this week. The reason? It is so very simple. You can prep just a single jar at a time, which makes it the perfect first canning project. Honestly, you don’t even need to do the hot water bath if you’re just making a jar or two for yourself, you can just stash your pickles in the fridge. Making pickles will build your canning confidence and get you excited for more ambitious projects. I’m certainly chomping at the bit for my next pickling project (onions and then okra). If I’ve got you sufficiently excited, my favorite refrigerator pickle recipe is right here.
I’m not going to be giving a jar of these pickles away, since this whole pickling thing is new to me, I want to wait and make sure they continue to be good for the weeks to come before I start handing them out, all willy nilly. However, do not despair. I’ve got another giveaway up my sleeve that will be coming soon.
Pickled Asparagus
adapted from Putting Up by Stephen Palmer Dowdney
4 pounds asparagus, trimmed to fit your pint jars and blanched in boiling water for approximately 10 seconds
3 cups vinegar (half apple cider vinegar, half white vinegar)
3 cups water
1/2 cup kosher salt
4 tablespoons Penzeys pickling spice
1 tablespoon red hot chili flakes
3 garlic cloves, peeled
3 slices of lemon
3 pint jars (if you use the taller, 12 ounce jelly jars, you don’t have to cut your asparagus quite as short and you’ll probably fill four jars. I didn’t have any, so I didn’t use them).
Sterilize your jars. Put the lemon slice in the bottom and pack the trimmed and blanched asparagus into the jars (it’s up to you to determine whether you want to go tips up or down). Tuck a garlic clove down into the asparagus spears.
Bring the vinegar, water and spices to a boil. Pour into jars on top of asparagus, leaving at least 1/2 inch of head space.
Put lids and rings on the jars and process in a hot water bath for 10 minutes (you can skip this step if you plan on just putting your pickles in the fridge).
Wait at least 24 hours before eating, to give the asparagus spears a chance to get sufficiently pickly.
Browse Timeline
Comments ( 20 )
[...] While I’ve been busy working on my project (which is now one full day behind schedule), Marisa has been busy pickling asparagus. [...]
Bits Of Dust » Blog Archive » Another Great Idea added this comment on Apr 26 09 at 11:21 pm[...] when I made the pickled asparagus, I ended up having some brine leftover after I filled the jars. Not wanting to be wasteful, I [...]
Food in Jars » Pickled Carrots and a Quick Brine Recipe added this comment on May 13 09 at 10:36 pm[...] green tomatoes. I used Marisa McClellan’s asparagus pickle recipe as a guide. Marisa is Philadelphia’s resident expert canner and always has great advice for putting [...]
On the same wavelength « DoughGirl added this comment on Aug 30 09 at 8:50 pm[...] of asparagus on sale, and decided to pickle the hell out of it. I used a recipe from the blog Food in Jars. It’s a great blog, but unfortunately in this case, the recipe was not a success. [...]
Pickled Asparagus Experiment | The Xen to One Ratio added this comment on Oct 02 09 at 12:32 am1. Rebekah Denn added this comment on Apr 25 09 at 1:25 amI think you’re right about pickling being the gateway to build “canning confidence.” We pickled cucumbers when we had a large garden in our East Coast years, and couldn’t get over (1) how good they tasted and (2) how straightforward they really were.
We have to try the asparagus — the commercial versions are insanely expensive!
2. Lelo added this comment on Apr 25 09 at 10:40 amThe tall jelly jars are perfect for asparagus, and so pretty. I tried my hand at pickling beets this week. Yummy.
Lelo, pickled beets are definitely on my list. -Marisa
3. Lori @ RecipeGirl added this comment on Apr 25 09 at 11:02 amI’m going to take your pickling excitement and get pickling. Asparagus is where I’ll start since I love to buy the terrifically expensive pickled asparagus that they sell in gourmet shops. I guess the trick is finding tall jars. I’d hate to cut them too terribly short. Thanks for the inspiration!
Lori, you’re welcome! Let me know if you have any questions! -Marisa
4. Erin added this comment on Apr 25 09 at 11:38 amYou are seriously making me want to pickle something right this second and I’m so not a food in jars kind of girl, but this website is making me want to become one. Plus I adore asparagus and love that you called this a meal “sidecar.” Keep up the awesome education please!
Erin, I’m so excited to be inspiring you to pickle something! -Marisa
5. andipantz added this comment on Apr 25 09 at 7:38 pmok you’ve inspired me. I am going to pickle something. Maybe an ex-boyfriend or five. Nah…I LOVE all things pickled. Now I just need to go buy some nice jars for doing such.
Andi, let me know if you have any pickling questions. I’m sure you’ll do fine though, as a woman with your skill at hummus making should have no trouble making an awesome pickle! -Marisa
6. Sylvie, Rappahannock Cook & Kitchen Gardener added this comment on Apr 26 09 at 12:33 pmThank you for encouraging people to pickle just a few jars at a time and keeping them in the fridge. It does not seem so daunting then…
a reminder to me too, who cans all summer long. I need to start earlier.
Have you ever pickle hardy greens (kale, mustard etc?)
Sylvie, I’ve never pickled hardy greens, but now that you’ve planted the idea, I really want to try it. Kale is one of my favorites, so now I can’t stop thinking about how it would be pickled. -Marisa
7. Sylvie, Rappahannock Cook & Kitchen Gardener added this comment on Apr 26 09 at 12:34 pmand I just reread the recipe! best part for me: no sugar. Too many pickling recipes come with sugar! so thank you for this one!
8. Tenaya Darlington added this comment on Apr 26 09 at 1:03 pmJust made a batch of pickeled cauliflower, and then I thought, “hmmmm…I have some asparagus…why not?” Any idea what’s in the Penzey’s Pickling mix if we don’t have it on hand?< /b>
The Penzeys mix contains mustard seeds, allspice, bay leaves, dill seeds, cloves, ginger, peppercorns, star anise, coriander, juniper berries, mace, cardamom and red peppers. You could try your hand at mixing a spice blend together of whatever of those items you happen to have on hand. Or if you have some other pickling spices that you particularly like, just substitute them. The original picklers made do with what they had, you can too. -Marisa
10. sarah gilbert added this comment on Apr 26 09 at 11:59 pmI’ve been meaning to try some pickled asparagus, but haven’t been able to reserve any asparagus yet. this weekend, surely, I’ll manage to save some.
I’m thinking allspice, cloves and pepper would be an especially nice combo. ooh… you’d also be interested in the delicious pickled carrots served w/sandwiches at the new Evoe, in the space next to Pastaworks. I thought I tasted dill and red wine vinegar. maybe I’ll ask for the recipe.
Sarah, pickled carrots are on the short list of things I hope to make soon. My favorite Philly farmers market opens on May 3rd, and so I’m hoping that there will be many delicious things that will inspire the next canning project. -Marisa
11. Tara added this comment on Apr 27 09 at 4:48 pmLast year I pickled cauliflower, green beans, and zuchinni. I can’t wait for the farmers market to open and the canning season to start here in Iowa!
![]()
13. sarah gilbert added this comment on May 21 09 at 1:27 pmso I did the pickled asparagus, but mine’s in a sour brine. after much deliberation I went with green garlic, hot pepper flakes, allspice, peppercorns, and nutmeg. early taste tests are delicious and I used your trick of saving the blanching liquid for watering plants (mine went on celery seeds I’m trying to encourage to sprout…)
I hope it’s good b/c a LOT of asparagus went into it!
14. Jim McGrath added this comment on May 22 09 at 9:28 amWhen I can my asparagus, I take the cut pieces 2 inches long and also can them. That is what the kids love.
15. Jessie added this comment on Jun 10 09 at 11:02 amThese are crying out for a bloody mary to float in…likewise for your soon-to-be pickled okra. Delicious!
17. Jase added this comment on Sep 15 09 at 2:29 amOMG!! Sorry to yell, but I made these the other day. They are the best! Ever! Can ‘ya tell I like them? Thank you soooo much for sharing the recipe. I took them to bible study tonight and everyone loved them. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I also made the grape katchup, it is absolutely fabulous. It was just great on chicken, next I plan on using it on flank steak for fajitas. I can’t wait.
18. Rhonda added this comment on Sep 23 09 at 1:07 amThis recipe didn’t work despite our best efforts. My asparagus shrivelled. It was as if the brine sucked the moisture from the stalks. A complete waste of time, product and effort.
19. Sam added this comment on Sep 27 09 at 9:13 pmDoh, mine shriveled as well!
![]()
When I went back and looked at the recipe, comparing to some other pickling brines I’ve used, it seems to have nearly twice the salt of the other brines – could there be an error in the recipe causing this problem? Something else going on?




